Real Estate News Business
 
Subscribe
 
                          
SEARCH
SITE WEB
  FEATURES

SAVE | EMAIL | PRINT | MOST POPULAR | RSS | REPRINTS

Exclusive Web Feature: Ensuring Accessibility: Multifamily Housing Developers Learn from FHA Litigation
Published: September 24, 2007

By David Kessler, Kessler McGuinness and Associates, LLC

Three years ago the multifamily housing industry collided with the Fair Housing Act (FHA) with several lawsuits alleging that some of the country’s largest developers had discriminated against people with disabilities in the design and development of thousands of residential units in hundreds of facilities across the country. One settlement requires over $20,000,000 of barrier removal and $400,000 in damages and legal fees.

The list of defendants reads like a who’s who of multifamily housing—Archstone-Smith, AvalonBay Trust, Bozzuto & Associates. The lawsuits allege “continuous and systematic civil rights violations against persons with disabilities” in the design and construction of dwelling units in multifamily projects across the country. Typical barriers cited include excessive slopes of exterior walkways and curb ramps; common use areas such as pools, locker rooms, and community kitchens that lack accessible elements; and bathrooms and kitchens in dwelling units without adequate clear maneuvering space.

A Wall Street Journal article reported that the plaintiffs had filed the lawsuits because "the number-one crisis for people with disabilities is obtaining accessible housing." In its 2006 annual report, HUD reported that there were more discrimination complaints under the FHA than ever before and the greatest number were based on disability.

Scrutiny of FHA compliance in multifamily housing is likely to continue for two reasons. First, their frustration with finding accessible housing remains high; and second, at least one major developer has responded to the litigation by agreeing to make their developments accessible rather than fighting compliance in court.

Fair Housing Act Requirements

Failure to design and construct multifamily dwellings with certain accessible and adaptable features became an act of discrimination in 1988 when the federal Fair Housing Act was amended to include people with disabilities as a protected class. The design standards, however, defining compliance with the FHA’s non-discrimination provisions are confusing. The FHA does not reference a single accessible design standard.

At first, the FHA recognized two “safe harbors” for satisfying its accessible construction requirements—either ANSI A117.1 or a state code into which the requirements of the FHA Amendments had been incorporated. Subsequently, HUD issued the Fair Housing Accessibility Guidelines, followed by the FHA Design Manual, to help interpret the guidelines. To date, the FHA Accessibility Guidelines along with seven other design standards are recognized by HUD as compliance “safe harbors” (see sidebar below for all eight safe harbors).

In an industry that has every-day experience complying with building codes, dealing with a civil rights law with multiple possible compliance standards has presented some pitfalls, including:

Two ground floors:
In buildings without elevators all ground floor units must be compliant. In 2/3 or 3/4 splits, there are typically two ground floors. All single story units on both ground floors must be accessible—even when there is no vehicular access to the “terrace” level. The one exception to this requirement is if any of the entrances meet the site “impracticability” test.

Not everything is “adaptable.”
Adaptability does not apply to all of the FHA requirements. The FHA Guidelines require some features of covered units to be accessible (i.e. the corridor side of the unit entrance door) and allow others to be adaptable (i.e. removable cabinets under sinks). For example, bathrooms with in-swinging doors must have a minimum of 30-in. by 48-in. out of the swing of the door. This clear space allowing a person using a wheelchair or scooter to enter and close the door cannot be provided by reversing the swing at a later date when needed. It must be provided at the time of first occupancy.

Finished surfaces at removable cabinets:
Cabinets are allowed under certain sinks and cooktops if the cabinet is “easily removable.” Often overlooked is the requirement that where cabinets are removable, the floor, wall and cabinet faces of the knee space be finished during initial construction so no other work is necessary when the base cabinet is removed. The small additional expense to continue flooring, baseboard, cabinet finish, and paint is considered an acceptable cost at the time of construction, as opposed to the difficulty of matching materials at a later date—often under different ownership—when the unit is adapted.

Detectable warnings:
Because the leasing or sales offices of multifamily developments are "places of public accommodation" under the ADA, these facilities, including associated parking and walkways, must meet the ADA Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG), as well as the FHA Accessibility Guidelines. Although the ADAAG requirement for detectable warnings was suspended,s it has been renewed since July or 2006. Since that time, all curb ramps in accessible paths of travel to public accommodations (i.e. leasing and sales offices) are required to have detectable warning.

Centered clear space:
The 30-in by 48-in. clear space required at appliances and fixtures such as ranges, sinks, refrigerators, and bathtubs must be centered. The centered clear space must be parallel to ranges. At all other fixtures and appliances it can be either a parallel or front approach.

There are several steps developers can take to help prevent common errors in FHA compliance:

Safe Harbor:
Decide which “safe harbor” will be used for your project at the beginning of the design process. If the local building code is not a safe harbor then it is critical to analyze where they differ. One element that is increasingly becoming an area of conflict is the maximum balcony door threshold allowed by the FHA vs. the requirement for greater water and wind protection instituted in some local codes since Katrina.

Plan for construction tolerances:
Where required maneuvering space is designed to absolute minimum dimensions there is no room for construction tolerances. For example, the application of tile as a wall finish could decrease the clear floor space below the minimum required.

Show actual appliance installation.
KMA often reviews plans showing U-shaped kitchens with the required 60-in. turning diameter and the refrigerator is shown flush against the wall. If the installed position of the refrigerator is any distance off the wall it will protrude into the required clear turning space. Therefore, take into consideration the actual installation requirements for the specified refrigerator model.

Perform FHA compliance plan review:
Plan reviews specific to FHA compliance, whether performed in-house or by a consultant, can catch the mistakes that often occur when designers are juggling multiple program demands. Reviews early in design development are most helpful in identifying the broader scoping issues while reviews of 90 percent DD or a CD set are best for catching non-compliant details.

Spell out FHA compliance in construction contracts.
Even when designed correctly, projects may not be built to the discerning standards of accessible design. For example, walkways may have cross-slopes of 3 percent, when the maximum allowed under ADAAG and FHA is 2 percent. Some developers actually give their contractor a “SmartLevel” and ask them to certify compliance with slope and cross-slope requirements at all walkways and accessible parking spaces.

Making FHA compliance a prominent goal of the development team and a clear measurement of a project’s success can ensure that multi-family developers avoid the errors that lead to lawsuits and the subsequent expense of providing a remedy after the fact.

David Kessler is a Principal of Kessler McGuinness and Associates, LLC, nationally recognized experts in accessibility planning and universal design.


8 Safe Harbors

1. HUD’s March 6, 1991 Fair Housing Accessibility Guidelines (the Guidelines) and June 28, 1994 Supplemental Notice to Fair Housing Accessibility Guidelines: Questions and Answers about the Guidelines.

2. ANSI A117.1-1986, used in conjunction with the Act and HUD’s regulations, and the Guidelines.

3. CABO/ANSI A117.1-1992, used in conjunction with the Act and HUD’s regulations, and the Guidelines.

4. ICC/ANSI A117.1-1998, used in conjunction with the Act and HUD’s regulations, and the Guidelines.

5. Code Requirements for Housing Accessibility 2000 (CRHA), approved and published by the International Code Council (ICC), October 2000.

6. International Building Code 2000 (IBC) as amended by the IBC 2001 Supplement to the International Codes.

7. Fair Housing Act Design Manual, 1996, U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

8. 2003 International Building Code (IBC).

SAVE | EMAIL | PRINT | MOST POPULAR | RSS | REPRINTS

  RECENT FEATURE HEADLINES

Emeral Terrace
Case Study: StarPoint Properties’ Makeover of LA’s Emerald Terrace Took Guts and Submarket Savvy
Emerald Terrace, located in the Koreatown neighborhood of downtown Los Angeles, was an asset that hadn't been maximized by the previous owner. Here's how StarPoint Properties set about implementing its ambitious repositioning plan over a 19-month period.


EDITOR'S NOTE: Storm Surges
The fallout from natural and man-made storms continues to swirl around us. Between the hurricanes and the continuing upheavals in the financial world, these truly are unsettled times. While I’d planned on writing about a different topic, yesterday’s historic plunge on Wall Street compelled me--and perhaps you, too?--to explore safe harbors and lifelines.


JoAnna_Brandi
Create an Upbeat, Can-Do Workforce and Dazzle Residents
The real challenge of "relationship management" is the relationships. Managers, in addition to making sure the work gets done, need to be concerned with the performance of the most important link in the customer connection--people. Here are 11 useful tips for developing a more upbeat, solution-oriented staff. 


Property Management: Retaining Residents by Building a Sense of Community
The top amenity desired by residents isn’t a granite counter-top, six-panel doors and crown molding. It’s a sense of community that cuts across luxury, A, B and C-grade properties


PROPERTY MANAGEMENT: Are You Leveraging The True Value of Internet Listing Services?
Jeff Smedley of CallSource makes the case for implementing an effective lead management system


EDITOR'S NOTE: In the Shadow of the Financial Crisis
Phew! What a week! Our very own event Multi-Housing World 2008 Conference and Exhibition was held in Denver last week. Within less than a week—a week—prior to the conference starting, the following happened: The government took over Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Lehman Brothers collapsed, and the sale of Merrill Lynch was announced. And on the day the conference began, on Wednesday, the newspapers were filled with reports of the government bailout of insurance giant AIG. The next day, the stock market plunged. And by the end of our three-day educational and networking get-together, the Administration had gotten together with members of Congress to announce what is now its proposed $700 billion financial securities purchase plan.


Multi-Housing New TV Launches Today
In our ongoing efforts to expand the Multi-Housing News digital products, MHN TV will launch on our Web site today. In the first segment, six industry people weigh in on the bailout of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and AIG.


MHW
Multi-Housing World Countdown
Leader's Panel: A View from the Top


Fogelman
Profile: Fogelman Management Focuses on Company Culture
Mark Fogelman is president and COO of the Fogelman Management Group (FMG), a privately held, full-service property management organization founded in 1963. FMG, based in Memphis, Tenn., manages 51 properties and 18,000 apartments, covering 12 states and 21 cities throughout the Midwest and Southeast. Five hundred and fifteen employees help to maintain FMG's high rankings, shown by its continuous placement in the top 10 of Ellis National Benchmark's listing for shopping reports–-in the second quarter of 2008, the company obtained sixth place out of 47 companies. FMG also takes pride in its philanthropic program, Fogelman Cares, through which the firm was able to raise enough money in just three months this year to grant two wishes through the Make-A-Wish foundation.


Case Study: Redeveloping Long Island City with Luxury Condominiums
Kana Kakihara-Oh, ASID, partner of New York-based DeArch LLC, discusses Roe Development’s newest luxury condominium, Star Tower, located in Long Island City, Queens. She explains the project’s aesthetics and challenges, as well as how it fits into the neighborhood’s redevelopment.


Editor's Note: Back to School
Back to school is a time of mixed emotions for many. While it means that the endless days and nights of summer are over—remember how long July and August felt when you were a kid?—fall brings an energy and excitement of its own. It’s a time of new school clothes, of stationery and supplies plastered with the latest pop culture icons, and the fresh pages of brand-new notebooks and binders, their blank sheets brimming with promise and potential.


MHW
Multi-Housing World Countdown
Opening Session: The National Real Estate Economy


EDITOR'S NOTE: Business as Usual…for Now
As the government places Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in conservatorship, what we can keep in mind for now is that the plan reportedly is meant to allow for the continued operations of the two companies while the rescue is taking place.


Labor Pains
Doesn’t it always seem ironic that yesterday’s Labor Day is when most of us—happily—tend to do the least amount of actual labor? It’s a great tradition, originated in 1882 when the Central Labor Union of New York City sought to create "a day off for the working citizens." Labor Day became a federal holiday in 1894 in one of Congress’ better moves.


BobKoch
Perspective: A New Vision for Seniors Housing
As the emerging population of baby boomers enter their pre-retirement and retirement years, they are bringing to the market a new variety of housing objectives, activity interests and product responses to consider. They are not the generation that preceded them. Their interests, lifestyle, financial capacities, and tastes are the result of a body of life experiences that differ dramatically from seniors in the earlier era.


Case Study: Brownfield Redevelopment Brings Mixed-Use, Mixed-income Residences to Denver
Jim Johnson, AIA, founder and principal of JG Johnson Architects in Denver and a past chair of the Denver Partnership Housing Council, discusses his firm’s work on a new mixed-use, mixed-income, transit-oriented development in Denver. When completed, Alexan Broadway Station will be comprised of 479 units and 14,000 sq. ft. of retail space and public amenities.


Ely
Seven Keys to Improving Resident Retention Rates
Too often, I see multifamily housing managers put all their efforts behind fancy sales and advertising promotions to bring in new tenants. New business is great—don’t get me wrong—but what if you were able to fill your entire complex without having to go to great lengths to pull in new residents? What if you were able to re-sign the majority, if not all, of your tenants with a proactive resident retention plan? What if this plan involved little cost to you? Do I have your attention yet?


EDITOR'S NOTE: The Industry Prefers Status Quo for Fannie and Freddie
In the past week, press reports seem to be intensifying in regards to the need for a government bailout of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.


Nelson
Development Perspective: Impact Fees Frequently Impact Multi-Housing Unfairly
www.multi-housingnews.com


First Solar-Powered Housing Project in India Complete, Sold Out
New Town Kolkata (Calcutta), India--India’s first solar-powered housing project, Rabi Rashmi Abasan, has been completed and sold out. Conceived, designed and built by West Bengal Renewable Energy Development Agency (WBREDA) and Bengal DCL Housing Development Co. Ltd., a joint enterprise of West Bengal Housing Board and DC Properties Ltd., the 600,000-Euro housing community is comprised of 25 residential bungalows and a community center on 1.76 acres.


Feldman
Profile: NALP of Year Winner Feldman Says, 'Leasing Is about People, not Property'
Thomas Feldman is the proud recipient of the 2008 National Apartment Leasing Professional (NALP) of the Year title from the National Apartment Association Education Institute (NAAEI). Feldman leases apartments at 100 Memorial Drive, a 260-unit building in Cambridge, Mass. He believes, "You really need to make the experience of a site visit more than just a live 'virtual tour.' By the end of the tour, I want my prospective resident to feel excited, not sold.”


EDITOR'S NOTE: Bowling, Anyone?
n the last two hours of a recent workday, my colleagues and I were scheduled to attend a group meeting, but one with a twist. We were all going bowling. Yes, bowling. Attendance was mandatory, which was an important factor because packing boxes for an office move (to a different floor in the same building) and deadlines for the September print issue were looming over us.


FINANCE & INVESTMENT: How a Real Estate Workout Works
As a first step to determining whether to participate in a loan workout rather than pursue foreclosure, the lender will try to find the cause of the property’s problems and whether it can be turned into a viable asset.


EDITOR'S NOTE: The Point of the Housing Act
The big news in recent weeks is the passage of the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008, described to be the most significant housing legislation in a generation. 


Case Study: The Need for Transit-Oriented Design in Long Beach, Calif.’s Redevelopment
Dan Withee, partner, and J. Roderick de la Rosa, senior associate, both of Torrance, Calif.-based Withee Malcolm Architects, discuss one of their latest projects, a mixed-use, transit-oriented development in downtown Long Beach, Calif.


 
  • Industry
  • Mhn About

Builders, developers, owners, architects, property managers and other professionals convene at Multi-Housing World to get the latest information they need to build their businesses, discover innovative products and network with peers.

Multi-Housing World 2008 Registration is Now Open.

CLICK HERE to download detailed MHW 2008 Show Planner

   
 
Produced by: Nielsen Business Media, a part of the Nielsen Company
Nielsen Hospitality Design | Kitchen & Bath Business | Display & Design Ideas
Multi-Housing News | Commercial Property News | Impressions
Multi-Housing News is the only real estate magazine that covers the multi-housing industry thoroughly, from multifamily trends to Residential Real Estate News. Multi-Housing News sets itself apart from competitive publications by its sheer devotion to the Multi-Housing industry and Residential Real Estate building industry. Through its exclusive Multi-Housing industry awards presentations and hugely popular Multi-Housing World conferences and Residential Real Estate and Building Expos, Multi-Housing News is a real estate magazine for professionals and proves that it has the industries future on its mind at all times. Whether it is through US housing market editorials, Multi-housing industry awards, green home trade shows or just reporting the latest news on the state of the Residential Real Estate, Multi-Housing News is appreciated globally as the leader in Multifamily and Multi-Housing industry information.
Multi Housing News Home | Real Estate News | Multifamily Real Estate Product Gallery | Multi Housing Industry Rankings |
Residential Real Estate Features | Multi Family Industry Events | About Multi-Housing News | Multifamily Trends Sitemap |
Advertising Opportunities | Media Kit | Contact Multi-housing News | Residential Real Estate Newsletter | Multi-housing Industry Tips


© 2008 Nielsen Business Media All rights reserved. TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY POLICY